1. No results to show.
Explore Services
Join as a pro
Log in
  1. No results to show.
  1. No results to show.
Home
Explore Services
Sign up
Log in

New Beginnings Wedding

Contact for price
Scheduling
Sorry this pro can’t do your job, but we know other pros who can. Check them out
About
it's "eyes wide open" during the wedding celebrations that I create WITH my couples. Yes, I listen to the thoughts and ideas of my couples and the ceremony SHOULD be about the couple and NOT the officiant. I'll bring years of ideas to our one meeting (usually 45 minutes to an hour) and lay the groundwork for a personal ceremony. The content and delivery is so well prepared. Some officiants repeat the same format over and over. Why? Every couple (and their families) are different. So should be their ceremony. As "cheezie" as it sounds I really do like meeting the variety of people and their cultures. Observing and orchestrating the wedding party at rehearsals in contrast to their perfection at "GAME TIME" is so rewarding. Oh - we do have fun but again, all with respect to the wishes of my couples. Everyone feels the respect.
Overview

Hired 13 times

1 employee

28 years in business

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, and PayPal.

Services offered
Type of ceremony

Wedding

Elopement

Commitment ceremony

Vow renewal

Service type (affiliation)

Christian

Catholic

Jewish

Muslim

Need help writing vows?

I can work with couples who need help writing vows

Projects and media
Projects and media
Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness.

Exceptional 5.0

18 reviews

5

100%

4

0%

3

0%

2

0%

1

0%

Read reviews that mention:

pro avatar
Terri M.

Jul 6, 2013

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Words can't begin to explain how wonderful Paul Costanzo was to work with. As a bride with a VERY shy fiance, I knew that I needed to find an officiant that was down to earth and easy to connect with. As soon as we met Paul, I knew that he was the one for us. He made sure that we were comfortable and happy with every aspect of our ceremony. He was so easy to talk with and has an outstanding personality. He emphasized that it was OUR ceremony and made sure that we felt comfortable with every part of our day. So many of our guests commented on how personal our ceremony was and what a neat guy Paul was. He really connected with us and I recommend him to anyone getting married.
Wedding Officiant
pro avatar
Kelsey M.

Oct 30, 2012

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Paul is an very personable officiant. He made our ceremony and rehearsal about us as a couple. He was great to work with and really put us at ease. We really enjoyed working with Paul and his wife Barb! Our ceremony would not have been the same without them.
Wedding Officiant
pro avatar
Jessica P.

May 31, 2016

•

Hired on Thumbtack

From beginning to end Paul was an amazing person to work with. After just one conversation we knew he was a perfect fit for the type of ceremony we were looking to have. He gave ideas and feedback, and helped in so many ways organize what we were trying to do (even with my last minute add ins). He got to know us and our family and really made the ceremony unique to us. We could not have asked for a more perfect day.
Non-Denominational Wedding Officiant
pro avatar
Allison Z.

Jan 21, 2016

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Words cannot fully describe our appreciation for Paul officiating our wedding. From the moment we met him, it was like he was family. He had so many ideas to make our ceremony 'ours' (from a wine box time capsule to encouraging guest participation) and was open to incorporating our 'quirky/unique' readings as well. We received MANY compliments for the ceremony and for Paul himself. Long story short, he is beyond exceptional!
Wedding Officiant
pro avatar
Heather W.

Nov 12, 2013

•

Hired on Thumbtack

On Nov. 10th, 2013 Rev. Paul performed our wedding ceremony at the Pfister Hotel in Milwaukee, WI. He exceeded our expectations on every level. When we met Paul we instantly felt like we were talking to a friend. He was a true professional and helped us create a beautiful, personal ceremony. All of our guests complimented us on Rev. Paul and said he did a wonderful job. We are so happy that we chose to work with Paul and would not have changed a thing about our ceremony. Thank you Rev. Paul!
Wedding Officiant

FAQs

  • How did you get started doing this type of work?

    Reverend Dennis (my predecessor) did personal ceremonies. When he moved to Phoenix he sold me the business because he saw in me the same qualities. The sincerity. The personality. The fine elements that blend with a couple to create the production for their families and guests.

  • What advice would you give a customer looking to hire a provider in your area of work?

    If you care about the content and delivery of your wedding celebration contact me and we'll get together for about 45 minutes to an hour - just one meeting. I know by the percentage of those who hire me that you will be quite pleased with the time we spend together along with the ideas that I bring to the table - and, of course, I listen to YOUR thoughts and ideas. I continue to say that the ceremony isn't about the officiant - it's about the COUPLE.

  • What questions should customers think through before talking to professionals about their project?

    Once we meet in person they will sense my genuine passion that I have for this service. Aside from Wedding Photography this is what I do best for my couples.

Related cost information

Popular in Muskego

You might also like

In other nearby areas

Thumbtack
Consider it done.
Customers
Pros
Support
© 2026 Thumbtack, Inc.
Thumbtack Guarantee