First Capitol Property Management
First Capitol Property Management

First Capitol Property Management

contact for price

Zip code
Sorry this pro can’t do your job, but we know other pros who can.
Introduction: Owning a rental property can be a great investment, but it can also cause major property management headaches. Even if you own just a single rental property, you could spend nearly all your time worrying about day to day tasks. In the face of all the work involved with property management, you need our skilled professional on your side. We’ll handle every piece of the property management puzzle, so you can stop worrying about your investment and focus on enjoying the benefits. Our skilled property managers serve York, Pennsylvania and the Mount Wolf, Manchester, Springettsbury, Dover, West Manchester, Windsor, Red Lion, Dallastown, Spring Grove, Hanover, Newberrytown, Wrightsville, Weigelstown, Spring Garden, Shiloh, North Codorus, Loganville, East York, and Lancaster County and its surrounding areas East Hempfield, Manor, Warwick, West Hempfield, East Lampeter, West Lampeter, Elizabethtown, Columbia, Salisbury, East Cocalico, Mount Joy, Lititz, Penn, and Upper Leacock areas. Our efficient systems and processes make our job very enjoyable as we work with owners, tenants, associations,and investors. We love managing and connecting people with great housing options.

Hired 10 times

Background checked

8 employees

17 years in business

Payment methods

Credit card

Featured Projects

3 photos

Management needs


Customers rated this pro highly for responsiveness, professionalism, and punctuality.

Great 4.8

9 reviews


Read reviews that mention:

pro avatar
Dillon W.
Feb 23, 2017
First Capital Property Management currently manages my first ever rental property. They were extremely helpful during the entire process. They filled in any knowledge gaps that existed, took care of finding the tenants, verified the quality of tenant to ensure only a quality tenant, supplied the lease, ensured it met the HOA's requirements for where the home is located and they take care of the ongoing management of the property. The fees are also competitive and very fair for all of the services they provide. They are always quick with their responses, openly communicate and are happy to answer any questions that you have throughout the process (believe me, I have asked many questions and often). I would recommend them to anyone looking to get into the rental property business or who are currently in the business and are looking for a better property management company. I will be continuing to use their services as I continue to invest in rental real estate and expand my portfolio.
pro avatar
Patricia m.
Nov 19, 2016
I came to know about First Capitol Property Management in September 2016. The house I live in is very old and in need of many repairs. My manager Nicole has gone above and beyond to help with anything that might come up. Of all the management companies I've worked for over the years, this company is the most PROFESSIONAL and they really do care about their tenants. They gget back to you in a timely manner and they will do their best to help in any situation or answer any questions you might have. I would highly recommend tis management company to anyone.
pro avatar
Seana P.
Jun 13, 2018

Hired on Thumbtack

Hired on Thumbtack

The team at First Capitol Management has been very friendly, professional, and helpful at every step of the process.

Details: Home(s) • No, only one • On-site management • Vacant

First Capitol Property Management's reply
Thanks Seana, We appreciate your kind words!
Property Management
pro avatar
Dennis M.
May 9, 2017

Hired on Thumbtack

Hired on Thumbtack

She is so professional and people and service focused. I would recommend her company
First Capitol Property Management's reply
Thanks Dennis! We appreciate your kind words!
Property Management
pro avatar
Janie M.
Feb 21, 2017
Excellent service! A pleasure to deal with such professionals and affordable too!
First Capitol Property Management's reply
Thanks so much! We are looking forward to continuing to offer great services to you!
Background Check

Nicole Byrd


  • What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?

    Our pricing structure is based on a percentage of monthly rents. We always take into consideration the amount that the property owner needs to get for the property and evaluate the rental rate based on including our percentage fee as well. We will work hard to get the rent that you would like and the best tenant for your property.

  • What is your typical process for working with a new customer?

    We will meet you at your property and walk through and answer all your questions from start to finish. We will then setup everything up to start marketing and showing your property. We typically can have a tenant in place within 30 days.

  • What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?

    All of our property managers have extensive property management training certificates from PMI University and we hold Real Estate Sale Licenses in the State of Pennsylvania and Maryland.

Not what you’re looking for?

No problem: we have pros for every job.