If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
About
For over 10 years, I’ve built my business on one core value: trust. As a one-person operation, I’m the only person who comes into your home and I’m responsible for every step of the job—from quote to clean-up.
I specialize in Water Softeners, Filters, toilet, sink, and faucet repair and installation, as well as water heaters, sump pumps, and garbage disposals. My focus is on high-quality workmanship, clear communication, and reliable results. No rushed jobs, no surprise changes—just honest recommendations and careful attention to detail.
If you’re looking for a dependable pro you can feel comfortable having in your home, I’d be glad to help.
Overview
Hired 13 times
Serves West Milford, NJ
Background checked
1 employee
11 years in business
Business hours
This pro hasn't listed their business hours.
Payment methods
This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Venmo, and Zelle.
Services offered
Types of furniture
Additional services
Projects and media
Projects and media
Reviews
Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and value.
Exceptional 5.0
15 reviews
5
100%
4
0%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
Your trust means everything to us. Learn about our review guidelines.
Read reviews that mention:
B.Marshall H.
Oct 3, 2026
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Casey responded very quickly, adjusting his estimate so it was affordable. He showed 10 minutes early, informed about water system in our recently purchased home and did very quick, quality work. I was operating in a short amount of time.
He also advised about system maintenance and upkeep. Very professional and friendly.
'll be calling him for any future plumbing needs.
Details: 0 sinks • One handle controls both hot and cold water • 1 faucet • A month ago or longer
Right Choice's reply
thank you
Sink or Faucet Repair
Saurabh K.
Oct 8, 2026
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Excellent service! Professional, punctual, and highly knowledgeable. The work was completed efficiently with great attention to detail. Highly recommend for reliable, quality plumbing services!
Details: 2 toilets • Municipal water (most common) • House
Toilet Repair
Michael I.
Oct 6, 2026
•
Hired on Thumbtack
My water heater needed replacement under warranty. Casey was more than happy to help. He, without a doubt, was infinitely more concerned about getting me hot water and he was about anything else. Wow, in the end, I was not able to hire Casey, I was. Incredibly impressed with his attitude, commitment to his trade, and his willingness to help. I would absolutely recommend him based on that alone.
Details: Yes, the location has an existing heater • Electric tank • I already purchased the water heater • House
Water Heater Installation or Replacement
Amber D.
3 weeks ago
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Casey and his helper Garrett were great. I initially contacted him because I needed a toilet installed, slow leaks in two of bathroom sinks fixed, and my water softener assessed. Casey took the time to visually show me what was wrong in my house and thoroughly explain the options we had to fix the problem. He was punctual and highly responsive. His work was fast and high-quality. They did a great job of leaving the area clean. I thought his pricing was fair. We’ll definitely be using him more in the future.
Handyman
Joanne p.
4 weeks ago
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Casey is a great guy. His work is impeccable and is done quickly and easily. You can count on him to get the job done right. I will be using his services for future projects. Thanks Casey..
Details: 2 - 5 hours (A few different projects) • Maintenance • Cleaning • Deck or porch • Home
Handyman
Credentials
Background Check
James Neal
FAQs
What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?
Right Choice holds a New Jersey Sate license for Backflow Testing to protect NJ drinking water from cross contamination.I have extensive knowledge on Sewage, Storm Water, Sump, and Booster Pump systems and controls
How did you get started doing this type of work?
I got atarted about 15 years ago as a sales person for a well known plumbing supply company.
What types of customers have you worked with?
We have worked with Residential, Commercial, Light Industrial, and Municiple customers.