Long Island Exterminating co
Long Island Exterminating co

Long Island Exterminating co

Offers remote services
Discounts available
Offers remote services
Discounts available
contact for price

Select a service
Zip code
Total square footage of building
Ability to vacate property
Sorry this pro can’t do your job, but we know other pros who can.
Introduction: What sets us apart from hiring just any Pest Control company is that we use organic, child and pet friendly chemicals. So, no need to evacuate your home. It is safe to stay home while we safely remove your unwelcome pests and wildlife. We are consistently ensuring that we are up to date with today’s trends and technologies. We strive on customer service; our Huntington, Five Boroughs and Long Island exterminators are continuously working hard to satisfy customer needs and requests. This has given Long Island Exterminating Co. a reputation as the most trusted and reliable company, serving Huntington, Long Island, and the 5 Boroughs of NYC. In addition we provide a discount to all veterans, police, firefighters, and frontline workers for their bravery and support.

Current Top Pro

Hired 117 times

Background checked

17 employees

63 years in business

Payment methods

Cash, Check, Credit card, PayPal, Venmo

Social media


Currently a top pro

Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.

All year

Current Top Pro

This pro indicated that they reviewed CDC safety guidelines for COVID-19 and pledged to do the following:

Maintain 6 feet of distance from customers

Wear masks during the job

Wear gloves during the job

Disinfect surfaces touched during the job

Featured Projects

37 photos


Customers rated this pro highly for professionalism, responsiveness, and work quality.

Excellent 4.9

107 reviews


Read reviews that mention:

Sherri E.

Pest Control Services

I had such a good experience with this company!!! Matt was super responsive, and helped me with my bug issue right away! He went above and beyond, and I could not be more grateful for how quickly and efficiently he worked!
Long Island Exterminating co's reply
Thank you Sherri we greatly appreciate it you reaching out to us and that kind review it was a pleasure working with you and thank you once again for those kind words if you need ANYTHING we are here to HELP
Mar 21, 2021
Michelina C.

Pest Control Services

Due to a sudden ant infestation in my home the week of March 1st, 2021 and after trying to take care of the infestation myself but failing miserably, I went online on Saturday, March 6th to research several exterminating companies. Matt Schenker, of Long Island Exterminating was the first to respond to my call. He said he would be happy to help and could be at my home by 1PM that afternoon. I mentioned I was reluctant to call an exterminator because of my allergies and sensitivity to chemicals. He assured me he would use a less toxic solution that would not stir up my allergies, it would be odorless and would work just as well. Upon meeting Matt that afternoon at my home It was obvious to me I hired the right guy! He was professional, experienced knowledgeable, personable and above all he really cared about doing a great job for me in solving my infestation. He explained everything he was going to do as we walked from room to room. He treated the entire outside and every room on the inside of my home, including the garage at a very fair price point and informed me his work was guaranteed. All that being said, the best part of this experience was . . . The next morning, there was "Not An Ant To Be Found!" Not one! I called to thank him again for doing such a great job! I recommend Matt and his company, Long Island Exterminating highly! M. Celli
Mar 11, 2021
Jay H.

Rodent and Animal Removal

Matt responded quickly and was available to arrive at the property promptly. He answered all my questions and was clear/concise on the process to remedy, as well as pricing. I am very satisfied with the job and will be using Long Island Exterminating for any of my future issues. Highly recommended.
Mar 5, 2021
Lisa W.

Pest Control Services

Matt was wonderful to work with and so far everything he has done has kept the ants we have been seeing at bay...something the big brand exterminators have been unable to do. He also gave us a realistic price upfront. I received other quotes at very lowball rates. (Knowing they would be raised once they got here). Matt’s price was fair plus he stands behind it for 30 days.
Long Island Exterminating co's reply
Thank you Lisa much appreciated happy and healthy new year
Dec 31, 2020
Ella And Nick S.

Pest Control Services

Matt was extremely professional, knowledgeable, and happy to answer all my questions. While he just did the work 2 days ago (will hopefully keep the mice away), I can say that I had a very good experience and I definitely recommend LI Exterminating to others who are considering their services.
Dec 6, 2020
Background Check

Matthew Schenker


  • What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?

    Pricing is based on a case by case situation. Bed bugs are done in a per room circumstance.

  • What is your typical process for working with a new customer?

    Meet the customer where the service needs to be done. Then look at the pest control problem, evulate the situation and get the job done.

  • What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?

    Have to keep our licenses up to date and take regular classes

Not what you’re looking for?

No problem: we have pros for every job.