Cindy's Catering Crew

Contact for price

Select a service

Zip code

Scheduling

Budget

Estimated guest count

Responds in about 20 min

Thumbtack Guarantee

If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more

About

We have been in business for over 10 years. We come into your home we help you set up for your event. We clean up we serve we put the food away. We want you just to sit back relax and enjoy your event. When we leave, it looks like you never had a party in your home. We serve we bartend and we barbecue. I can help create signature drink menus for your event.

Overview

Hired 26 times

Serves Oceanside, NY

Background checked

3 employees

11 years in business

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Venmo, and Zelle.

Top Pro status

Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.

2025

Services offered

Beverage types

Event type

Wedding reception

Birthday party

Special occasion

Cocktail party

Event vibe

Low key / casual

Formal / elegant

Upbeat / lively

Club scene

Projects and media

Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness.

Exceptional 5.0

17 reviews

5

100%

4

0%

3

0%

2

0%

1

0%

Read reviews that mention:

Libby G.

May 5, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

I’m so very glad I hired Cindy!! I was skeptical of thunbtack, but she was so perfect! I’ve been doing this birthday party myself for the last few years, but we had more people this year. We’ll be hiring her again- she took care of everything and everyone! I picked up food and she took care of the rest. And her bartending skills were absolutely perfect, she got so many compliments! So very happy with Cindy- we’ll be hiring her again!

Details: Birthday party • 51 - 100 guests

Cindy's Catering Crew's reply

Thanks for the great review I appreciate it!

Event Help and Wait Staff

Davey C.

Mar 22, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: 11 - 25 guests • Special occasion • Low key / casual • Private residence • Liquor / mixed drinks • Wine • Non-alcoholic beverages • Venue will already have a bar • Tip jars not allowed

Bartending

Tamara B.

Dec 12, 2025

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Cindy was the bartender for our Engagement Party at a private venue. She was very responsive upfront and gave me a very reasonable price. Also was super flexible and said she could stay longer if needed, which we ended up having her stay anyway. She came early and super professional. She was responsible for mainly our 2 signature cocktails which she made perfectly and even thought most other drinks were supposed to be self-serve she ended up serving people anyway. She was attentive and helped with picking up empty glasses and tidying up around tables. Also, my dad couldn’t figure out how to use the goat coffee maker and she was able to help him out- very sweet of her. She made our day so special and I would definitely hire her again!

Details: 51 - 75 guests • Special occasion • Low key / casual • Public venue • Liquor / mixed drinks • Venue will already have a bar • Tip jars not allowed

Bartending

Donna R.

Jul 13, 2025

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: 11 - 25 guests • Cocktail party • Low key / casual • Private residence • Beer • Liquor / mixed drinks • Wine • Non-alcoholic beverages • Venue will already have a bar • Tip jars not allowed • Setup / cleanup

Bartending

Andrew Y.

Jun 15, 2025

•

Hired on Thumbtack

The most responsive bartender I’ve ever hired, helped me set everything up with no hassle on my end, my party guests loved her drinks! Everyone had a good time with her bartender skills!

Details: 11 - 25 guests • Birthday party • Upbeat / lively • Private residence • Liquor / mixed drinks • Non-alcoholic beverages • Bartender will need to bring the bar • Tip jars allowed

Bartending

Credentials

Background Check

Cindy Hayes