Rewind Time Painting Company LLC

Top Pro

Free on-site estimate

Select a service

Zip code

Number of rooms

Paint supplier

Wall condition

Responds within a day

Thumbtack Guarantee

If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more

About

My focus is to bring your home back to a previous time when things felt great, felt brand new. I want my work to evoke positive emotions and reflect meticulous craftsmanship.

Overview

Current Top Pro

Hired 4 times

Serves Mc Sherrystown, PA

Background checked

2 employees

1 year in business

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Credit card, and Square cash app.

Services offered

Painting type

Property type

Home

Business

New construction

Painting for new construction

Painting for existing buildings

Projects and media

Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and punctuality.

Good 4.2

5 reviews

5

80%

4

0%

3

0%

2

0%

1

20%

Karen M.

Feb 24, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: Wall cabinets • 11-15 cabinets • Wood stain • Full repainting in darker color • Owner

Cabinet Painting

Brandee C.

Feb 24, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Matthew and his crew did my ENTIRE house and it looks amazing, we are ready to sell! Not only did it look great he was so flexible but still worked hard to get it done by the deadline. Professional, quality product, great staff. Will be using him again in my new home.

Details: Home • 8+ rooms • Trim • Walls • Doors • 8 - 10 feet (standard ceiling) • Repainting, with same color • Repainting, with a color change • Fair - minor holes and scratches • No, this is not new construction • No, I will move things out of the way myself

Interior Painting

Elizabeth B.

Dec 19, 2025

Matthew did an amazing job. He painted one of our rental properties. We will definitely use him for all of our properties moving forward.

Emran A.

Jan 1, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Very nice guy, knowledgeable, professional, on time does very good job

Details: Home • 1 room • Ceiling • 8 - 10 feet (standard ceiling) • I'm flexible • Fair - minor holes and scratches • Homeowner or property manager • No, this is not new construction • No, I will move things out of the way myself

Interior Painting

Kelli W.

Feb 24, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Absolutely the WORST company to work with. The owner named Matt threatened me with the Police if I don't pay him for his LESS THAN PROFESSIONAL job. I had a Realtor come over to my house to review the paint job which was done 3 days ago. He noticed that EVERY WALL SEAM bled into the other wall and there were spots all over the ceiling and the walls that needed to be fixed. When I let Matt know the situation he was unprofessional, rude, and threatening. Now, I have to hire another paint company to come in and FIX all the problems before I sell my house.

Details: Home • 2 rooms • Walls • Trim • Ceiling • 8 - 10 feet (standard ceiling) • I'm flexible • Excellent - clean and smooth • Homeowner or property manager • Yes, this is new construction • I'm flexible

Rewind Time Painting Company LLC's reply

this claim is absolutely false. me and my team did exceptional work for this woman however it is our theory that during overnight hours she took pictures of incomplete work and is trying to pass them off as our company's complete work I beg any and all contractors who deal with this woman to stop immediately or refrain from doing so.

Interior Painting

Credentials

Background Check

Matthew Dudash

FAQs

What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?
In home estimates are always free. Benchmark pricing guide is available.
What is your typical process for working with a new customer?
first I would like to be in contact with them via ***** or *****, at that point I would like to set up a in-home estimate or a short description over those methods that I can give a benchmark estimate for. you will be treated with respect and you will be given patience and options that best fit you and your needs.
What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?
over two decades of painting experience. Clean, fast precise and friendly.