

Old Fashion Café
$100
Starting price
Scheduling
Budget
Responds within a day
Thumbtack Guarantee
If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
Introduction
OLD FASHION CAFE – YOUR ITALIAN CATERING IN NEW YORK
When you choose Old Fashion Cafe’s catering, you bring the quality, tradition, and innovation of Italian cuisine to your event. Our mission is to deliver an authentic culinary experience that impresses your guests with refined flavors and carefully selected ingredients.
WHAT MAKES US UNIQUE?
1. HIGH-QUALITY INGREDIENTS
We source only fresh, premium ingredients, prioritizing Italian DOP and IGP products to ensure the highest quality and flavor.
2. CUSTOMIZED MENUS FOR EVERY OCCASION
From corporate meetings to private events, we tailor our menus to meet your needs, elevating every detail with refined and authentic dishes.
3. THE ART OF THE ITALIAN APERITIVO
We specialize in finger food and Italian-style buffets, offering everything from traditional charcuterie boards with premium cured meats and cheeses to gourmet bites like arancini, artisanal focaccia, and mini stuffed sandwiches.
4. AUTHENTICITY MEETS INNOVATION
We respect Italian culinary traditions but are not afraid to innovate. Our chefs reimagine classic dishes with a modern twist, perfectly suited for the New York audience.
5. PROFESSIONAL SERVICE & ATTENTION TO DETAIL
We don’t just serve food—we create an experience. Our highly trained staff ensures impeccable service, from setup to presentation.
Overview
Serves New York, NY
Background checked
14 employees
3 years in business
Business hours
This pro hasn't listed their business hours.
Payment methods
Ask this pro about their preferred payment method.
Services offered
Beverage types
Event type
Wedding reception
Birthday party
Special occasion
Cocktail party
Event vibe
Low key / casual
Formal / elegant
Upbeat / lively
Club scene
Projects and media
7 photos
Projects and media
7 photos
Reviews
Good 3.9
41 reviews
5
61%
4
12%
3
2%
2
5%
1
20%
Read reviews that mention:
Past Customer
Jan 15, 2025
·
From Google
From Google
This place is truly a gem a sleeper pick for high quality, just all around well made Italian food. The restaurant originated in Italy and it shows. Most of the wait staff are Italian and quite friendly. Definitely recommend coming here (and generally its not too busy - and crossing my fingers it stays that way)!
Past Customer
Jan 14, 2025
·
From Google
From Google
Posto molto tranquillo ma accogliente gestito da un ragazzo italiano simpaticissimo! Vi sapr dare tante info utili sulla citt grazie alle sue conoscenze.Cibo di ottima qualit che consiglio a tutti gli italiani e non in vacanza(Translated by Google)Very quiet but welcoming place run by a very nice Italian guy! He will be able to give you lots of useful information about the city thanks to his knowledge.Excellent quality food that I recommend to all Italians and not on holiday
Past Customer
Nov 24, 2024
·
From Google
From Google
It was extremely enjoyable to sit outside in the summer. The ambiance and location of the place are very nice. I had avocado toast, my boyfriend had a hamburger. I did not like the aperol . My avocado toast was 7/10, my boyfriend's had a hamburger 8/10.
Past Customer
Nov 10, 2024
·
From Google
From Google
The omelette is way better than breakfast omelettes usually are thanks to some nice crispy browning. The English breakfast phones it in on the other hand.
Past Customer
Jan 24, 2025
·
From Google
From Google
Only got drinks but loved the Italian atmosphere. Will absolutely be back for dinner.
Credentials
Background Check
Pietro Iacca