Simply Amazing Service Catering

Broken Arrow, OK

Get up to five quotes from pros like Simply Amazing Service Catering within hours. Get Quotes

About this pro

How does your business stand out?

My wife, Karen and I have over 50+ years combined catering experience. We know how to take care of our guests and how to anticipate your needs. Our passion is for you to feel like you have been treated like royalty. If you are a Bride or Groom (or a parent) you must know, this meal will be one of the most important meals you will ever eat, because it will live on in your memory along with your wedding. We take that responsibility very seriously. We are both also very conscious of our health and the way we eat. We are as gluten-free, dairy free and sugar free as we can possibly be. We know that not everyone is concerned with gluten or has other dietary concerns, but the number of people who are concerned is growing daily. We make our clients aware that in any catered event someone is likely to be either gluten sensitive or have other dietary issues. The number could be as high as 30% of your guests that could fall into this category and you don't want to leave them out, you also want your meal to be delicious and memorable. We are very knowledgeable of what it takes to make our clients and their guests happy. Karen also has a unique approach to setting up the buffet and the dining tables to work with the theme created by the bride or our client. She works with the color scheme and decor to compliment the overall look and feel of the event. We are concerned with the whole experience, what you see, smell and taste at the events we cater.

What do you enjoy about the work you do?

That this is not just a job for us, we live, think and breath Simply Amazing Service Catering. We are passionate about what we do, which is why we have been doing it for so long. We have been doing this "job" for others for a very long time and now we own this catering business to give our clients what we think is Simply Amazing Service.
{[{ questions.text }]}


Broken Arrow, OK 74014

Background check


Years in business


Number of employees


Times hired on Thumbtack



26 Reviews
  • Stephanie T. Apr 28, 2017
    Verified Review
    He was extremely nice and professional. Any questions I had he answered. I would definitely recommend him.
  • Nathan S. Apr 2, 2017
    Verified Review
    Great experience
    They served as bartenders for a conference of about 400 people. Fantastic job. Very easy to work with and reasonably priced.
  • Susan D. Oct 28, 2016
    Event Catering (Drop-off)
    Verified Review
    Excellent food!!!!
    The food was amazing and my guest kept asking all night where did we get the food. The service was excellent and quality was well worth it! Made our wedding day special. I would highly recommend and definitely use again.
  • Karen S. Oct 2, 2016
    Event Catering (Buffet)
    Verified Review
    An Amazing Expereince!
    Jerry and Karen catered a birthday party for my mother's 80th birthday. They were so easy to work with and the food was delicious! We had many compliments from our guests. I would gladly and highly recommend them for your next event.
  • Elisha S. Sep 29, 2016
    Event Catering
    Verified Review
    Lovely desserts!
    Sweet individuals with even sweeter treats! Beautiful setup and desserts for our event. Would recommend!
  • Stephen W. Sep 16, 2016
    Event Catering (Drop-off)
    Verified Review
    Excellent Food and Service!
    The food was excellent, and they made sure we had everything we needed to have a great wedding!
  • Micah L. Sep 12, 2016
    Wedding Catering
    Verified Review
    Good Deal !
    This catering company was great. They were helpful and willing to answer any questions. The food and service they provided at the venue was what we hoped for.
  • Rebecca R. Aug 14, 2016
    Wedding Catering
    Verified Review
    Simply Amazing Service Catering was outstanding. They usually replied within the hour, answering all of my questions. They took care of everything and I didn't have to even worry about anything. The food was delicious and the price is very responsible. They work with your budget and offer simply amazing service.
  • Debbie B. Aug 6, 2016
    Verified Review
    Wonderful - friendly, on time.
  • Cindy S. Jun 24, 2016
    Verified Review
    They were great! Spain Ranch looks forward to working with them again!
  • Ceci B. Jun 13, 2016
    Catered wedding was very good, including gluten-free wedding cake. Would recommend.
  • Mike C. Jun 13, 2016
    Verified Review
    Smooth, easy to communicate with!
  • Christopher S. Jun 6, 2016
    Everything was great!
  • Tamera A. Jun 6, 2016
    The service was absolutely amazing! I would definitely recommend it to friends and family. Outstanding job guys! Keep up the good work.
  • Kena R. Jun 6, 2016
    Jerry and Karen are amazing!!!! Their food is was delicious! Their drinks tasted great! Love the cucumber herb water. It was perfect! Their set up and display for our wedding was beautiful! They catered perfectly for my special food needs. As I have celiacs and can't have gluten. And the taste of the food was beyond good. And anyone who has to eat gluten free knows that if the food taste good gluten free you've hit the jackpot! Plus they did all this perfectly on short notice! We couldn't have asked for better service! Thank you very much for a wonderful, beautiful, and superbly done job! We truly enjoyed every bit!
  • Mick H. Jun 6, 2016
    Food was excellent w/attentive service.Seating and decor were appropriate and tasteful.
  • Kevin B. Jun 6, 2016
    The set up and food was just awesome and what's really great is the fact that my wife can only eat gluten free foods and Jerry and Karen to the extra care to make sure her plate had no gluten mixture --- awesome job and I highly recommend their service
  • Marie B. Apr 3, 2016
    Verified Review
    Wedding reception. Absolutely amazing job. My first daughters wedding and Jerry made it a very memorable night. The bride and groom as well as all the guest were very pleased. I would highly recommend Jerry and his staff for any special occasion. I will certainly use him again for any future events:)
  • Sara S. Dec 10, 2015
    Event Catering (Drop-off)
    Verified Review
    Simply Amazing Service Catering did an excellent job at my boss's annual reception event for his clients and cities. The food was wonderful, hot, and everyone loved the variety. I would recommend Jerry & his staff for any large event! We will use him again next year!
  • Dawn W. Nov 16, 2015
    Verified Review
  • Sue N. Jul 24, 2015
    Verified Review
    Jerry and Karen were wonderful to work with! They were very helpful, very professional, and ready to serve all evening. We were very pleased to have them at our gathering as they really contributed to how smoothly the evening went.
  • Jennifer D. May 13, 2015
    Verified Review
    Very helpful in the details of what we were looking for. Family and friends enjoyed their company. They made our celebration perfect. Jennifer
  • Stephanie S. Apr 26, 2015
    Event Catering (Drop-off)
    Verified Review
    Simply Amazing catering was just that: Simply Amazing! Not only did they work with me to create a fabulous menu for my wedding reception at a fantastic price, but also the food they served was mouth-watering and delicious! They showed up exactly on time, arranged and served the food for us, and even went around and collected dinnerware from my guests when they finished eating. Even though our dessert (wedding cake) wasn't furnished by them Jerry Gardner and his staff took it upon themselves to serve it for our guests!!! They cleaned up and put all leftovers in storage containers before they left our reception which made breaking down after our guests left a breeze! I cannot recommend them enough! If you don't use them to cater your next event then you WILL certainly be settling for less than th absolute best!
  • Stacey G. Dec 30, 2014
    Jerry and company with SAS Catering did an outstanding job at my wedding reception at Stinchcomb Mansion. I couldn't have been more pleased with everything!! They were such a pleasure to work with and made the entire process stress free. The food was excellent and service throughout the reception A++! They did such a wonderful job at my wedding reception; I also used them for two holiday luncheons at my place of employment. Will definitely use them again for a small or large event!
  • Jimmie H. Dec 29, 2014
  • Stephanie B. Dec 29, 2014
    Simply Amazing Service Did a wonderful job catering the Broken Arrow and Coweta Girl Scout holiday dinner. The food was absolutely delicious everything was on time and hot. The staff prepared, served and tidied up all so the members could enjoy this meal. I will use again. Thanks!


What types of customers have you worked with?
Buffets are much more common and practical for most events. They give our clients and their guests an opportunity to mingle, especially around action stations such as a carving station or a pasta station or the chocolate fountain. A buffet also provide a variety you will not get from a sit down meal.
Describe a recent project you are fond of. How long did it take?
We are blessed to work with several local venues, one of them is Stinchcombe Mansion in Broken Arrow. We recently catered a small wedding for a great couple. They were very happy with our service and the food so they did not have to worry about anything but having a good time. This is one of the most important days for the bride and groom but also their families, and everyone was happy.
What advice would you give a customer looking to hire a provider in your area of work?
If you are planning an important event, sit with the caterer and describe how you envision this event. Do you want a sit down, plated meal on china with many waitstaff, wine service and bartenders or do you want a buffet with disposable plates or something in between. Convey to the caterer what you wish for AND your budget, we are a creative bunch, we can probably provide for you what you want. Let the caterer help design the perfect menu for your event, you usually won't have to stick with a standard menu they have. We can make both Gluten-Free and standard recipe items, we can change sauces for most of the items, we can provide the protein, starch, vegetables and sweets you would like. We are flexible and we want you to be more than satisfied.