If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more
About
I pride myself on building a law firm that provides one-on-one legal counsel to its clients--and attorneys must devote personal attention to every client to maximize recovery and compensation. This personalized approach emphasizes strong relationships with our clients and taking the time to listen to their unique concerns.
Mr. Winegar is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, one of the most prestigious groups of trial lawyers in the United States, and membership is limited to attorneys based on strict qualifications. There are over 5000 members throughout the country. Fewer than 1% of U.S. lawyers are members.
Mr. Winegar has an Avvo rating of 10, the highest rating from Avvo calculated using information collected from State Bar associations and based on experience and peer endorsements, associations, and awards.
He was recognized in 2019 as “Best Personal Injury Lawyers in West Palm Beach” by Expertise, who scored personal injury lawyers on over 25 variables across five categories.
Overview
Hired 66 times
Serves Orlando, FL
Background checked
Verified business
License verified
6 employees
15 years in business
Business hours
This pro hasn't listed their business hours.
Payment methods
Ask this pro about their preferred payment method.
Top Pro status
Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.
2025
2024
2019
2018
Credentials
License verified
Attorney
License state: FL
Background checked
Passed by Joshua Winegar on Dec 4, 2025.
Business verified
Winegar Law, P.A. Florida
Services offered
Personal injury type
Work location
My customers travel to me
I travel to my customers
Projects and media
Projects and media
Reviews
Customers rated this pro highly for responsiveness, professionalism, and punctuality.
Exceptional 5.0
45 reviews
5
98%
4
2%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
Your trust means everything to us. Learn about our review guidelines.
Read reviews that mention:
Maura T.
Dec 25, 2018
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Extremely Prompt. Caring. I "had" hired an "Attorney Referral Firm", after seeing Ads on television, & after 5 months, nothing got done!
If you've been in a car accident & been injured, do your homework, HIRE a REAL Attorney, like Winegar Law!
Personal Injury Attorney
Jasmine D.
Nov 28, 2023
•
Hired on Thumbtack
He’s absolutely Amazing he helped me even though he is only PI he still took time to read the documents and explain to his best knowledge of the paperwork and even recommended an attorney who could further assist me I would definitely highly recommend him he’s not just for the money he really wants to help
Legal Document Preparation
Loona L.
Dec 29, 2021
•
Hired on Thumbtack
Winegar Law was extremely helpful even though my case was not in their work field they went out of their way to contact me console me and give me great advice. I can only imagine how great of lawyers they would be when taking in your case!
Personal Injury Attorney
Brett M.
Jun 19, 2018
•
From Google
Josh and his team are a group of prodigious, dedicated and hardworking people. They helped me when I was rear-ended in March of 2018. I reached out to him while I was lost and had no idea what to do as this was the first accident I have been in.When I called I was met with a warm welcome where I informed Josh about the situation and let him know the extent of my concerns, injuries, and damage to my vehicle. He laid out for me, very clearly, exactly how he would approach the case and each step he would take in settling my case. This put me at ease as the process and legal verbatim can get a bit confusing without a degree.He is a knowledgeable, experienced, successful attorney. More importantly, he is a compassionate, honest human being, which is essential when it feels as though your life is falling apart. I highly recommend him and his firm. My case turned out far better than I had hoped for.They were always in touch, always had all the answers to any questions. This law firm carried me and my family through the most horrible time of my life. They were always there for us day by day. It gave me time to concentrate on healing. A level of trust and caring that I will always be truly grateful for.I would highly recommend Josh if you are looking for somebody that not only cares about winning your case but also cares you as his client.
Brett M.
Jun 18, 2018
Josh and his team are a group of prodigious, dedicated and hardworking people. They helped me when I was rear-ended in March of 2018. I reached out to him while I was lost and had no idea what to do as this was the first accident I have been in. When I called I was met with a warm welcome where I informed Josh about the situation and let him know the extent of my concerns, injuries, and damage to my vehicle. He laid out for me, very clearly, exactly how he would approach the case and each step he would take in settling my case.
He is a knowledgeable, experienced, successful attorney. More importantly, he is a compassionate, honest human being, which is essential when it feels as though your life is falling apart. I highly recommend him and his firm. My case turned out far better than I had hoped for.
They were always in touch, always had all the answers to any questions. This law firm carried me and my family through the most horrible time of my life. They were always there for us day by day. It gave me time to concentrate on healing. A level of trust and caring that I will always be truly grateful.
I would highly recommend Josh if you are looking for somebody that not only cares about winning your case but also cares you as his client.
-Brett M.
FAQs
What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?
Contingency fee basis (33.3%). We work on a contingency-fee basis — we don’t get paid unless you win — so that you can afford to hire an excellent attorney to protect your interests.
Aside from eliminating any up-front costs, working on a contingency fee also incentivizes the attorney to recover the most compensation possible on your behalf.
Our pay is a reasonable percentage of the compensation you recover on your behalf, so you never have to worry about our firm advising you to take an inadequate settlement offer.
We recover only if you recover. If there is no recovery, then it is free and no costs to the client.
What is your typical process for working with a new customer?
There is an initial client consultation, which is free and we conduct a thorough intake to learn all the facts surrounding the incident and the damages and injuries sustained. Addressing the medical needs and helping clients get the medical attention they need is first and foremost. After we identify the responsible parties, we aggressively pursue settlement negotiations to resolve the case without litigation. However, if the case cannot be settled without litigation, we will file a lawsuit to pursue recovery.
What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?
I went to the University of Florida for undergrad and the #1 ranked law school in Florida at the University of Florida Levin College of Law.
I began my legal career with a nationally recognized trial defense firm, where I defended property owners, management companies, trucking companies, product manufacturers, and the largest insurance companies in the world. I now use my insight and knowledge of the inner workings of insurance companies’ claims evaluation procedures and extensive experience with defense tactics and techniques to pursue justice and protect the rights of individuals and families injured or killed.
