Five Star Brothers Painting & Staining

Top Pro

Free on-site estimate

Zip code

Scheduling

Deck or porch size

Deck services needed

Responds in about 2 hours

Thumbtack Guarantee

If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more

Introduction

Hi Everyone, My brother and I have been running our business for several years now and specialize in interior and exterior painting as well as carpentry and flooring. We have expanded our services to also offer wallpaper removal/installation, popcorn ceiling removal, flooring installation, and remodeling work. We have grown substantially in the past few years and are looking to keep that trend going by making sure all of our customers are happy with our work! We service all of Ocean and Monmouth Counties as well as the neighboring counties! We look forward to connecting with you!

Overview

Current Top Pro

Hired 218 times

Serves Lakehurst, NJ

Background checked

20 employees

5 years in business

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Credit card, PayPal, Venmo, and Zelle.

Social media

Instagram

Top Pro status

Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.

2024

2023

2022

Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness.

Great 4.8

119 reviews

5

93%

4

3%

3

1%

2

1%

1

2%

Read reviews that mention:

Amy H.

Oct 3, 2024

·

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: Home • 3 rooms • Trim • Walls • Ceiling • 8 - 10 feet (standard ceiling) • Repainting, with a color change • Fair - minor holes and scratches • Homeowner or property manager • No, this is not new construction • No, I will move things out of the way myself

Interior Painting

Peter A.

4 days ago

·

Hired on Thumbtack

I reached out to Matt for a full house paint job. Everything was very smooth from the very first exchange. Matt was one of the few people willing to provide an estimate based on pics/videos, with the understanding we will do a walk through later. The estimate ended up being spot-on, and pricing wise was very fair. The crew did an amazing job. Also importantly, Matt and Sean are both very responsive. I texted Matt almost daily throughout the project, and he was always very helpful and patient. It’s worth noting that Five Star Brothers does way more than paint, and I absolutely plan on using them in the future for other projects. We are extremely satisfied with our experience. If you are looking or still deciding, go to Five Star Brothers.

Details: Home • 8+ rooms • Walls • Trim • Ceiling • Doors • Window frames • 8 - 10 feet (standard ceiling) • Repainting, with a color change • Excellent - clean and smooth • Homeowner or property manager • No, this is not new construction • No, I will move things out of the way myself

Interior Painting

Desiree P.

May 15, 2025

·

Hired on Thumbtack

They did a great job on painting my Aunts room and hanging the TV and Curtain rods for her. Also did great job of filling 5 wall holes that you can’t see anymore. Wud use again.

Details: Both, wall and base cabinets • 1 cabinet • Paint • Full repainting in darker color • Yes, I will supply the paint to the professional

Cabinet Painting

EHAB O.

Apr 23, 2025

·

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: Home • Two stories • One part of building • Less than 500 sq ft • Brick • Stone • No visible exterior damage

Exterior Painting

Jason N.

Mar 14, 2025

·

Hired on Thumbtack

Details: Home • One story • Entire building • 1,000 - 1,500 sq ft • Vinyl • I’d like the professional to provide the paint • No visible exterior damage

Exterior Painting

Credentials

Background Check

Matthew Rittweger

FAQs

What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?
My pricing is calculated with linear and square footage measurements based on industry standards. Therefore, no matter where I am, my prices will always be the same. I do not partake in “zip code inflation.” We do provide military and senior citizen discounts!
How did you get started doing this type of work?
I started doing remodeling work in college and started up my own business on the side while still in school. Once I graduated, my brother and I started to grow our business since we were able to focus on it full time.
What types of customers have you worked with?
I’ve worked with customers from all different backgrounds and in various stages in their lives. Some of our clients have a lot of experience working with contractors where others have never worked with a contractor before working with us. We take pride in being thorough with our process so all of our customers are satisfied upon completion of their project.