1. No results to show.

Pastry by Day

Contact for price

Scheduling
Budget
Pastry type
Sorry this pro can’t do your job, but we know other pros who can. Check them out
Projects and media
Projects and media
About
Pastry and cake that is filled with thoughtful, high quality ingredients, with the aim of making your event as delicious as possible. Specializing in all butter (or vegan) buttercream cakes and inventive pastry catering services, Pastry by Day LLC is a small business committed to going beyond satisfaction, to surprise and delight each customer! I love seeing the delight on people's faces when they see the completed product for the first time, and the knowledge that Pastry by Day gets to be a small part of a much larger and more important event! Whether it's a birthday, anniversary, celebration, or wedding, I love having a small role in your special day. The design aspect is always a fun exploration and conversation between client and company, but my true satisfaction comes from the surprise and joy of the first bite!
Overview

Hired 13 times

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

Ask this pro about their preferred payment method.

Top Pro status

Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.

Top Pro Icon

2017

Services offered
Pastry type

Cakes

Cupcakes

Cake Pops

Cookies

Event type

Corporate event

Birthday party

Private party

Graduation

Work location

My customers travel to me

I travel to my customers

Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, and value.

Exceptional 5.0

11 reviews

5

100%

4

0%

3

0%

2

0%

1

0%

Read reviews that mention:


pro avatar
Meghan M.

Mar 16, 2016

Hired on Thumbtack

The cake Natalie made for my husband's surprise birthday party was outstanding. The design (a tombstone, in this case!) was spot on and the cake itself was one of the most delicious I've ever tasted (chocolate with cream cheese frosting). I would order another cake from her in a second. Highly recommended.
Cake Making Services
pro avatar
Michele C.

Jun 12, 2016

Hired on Thumbtack

Great customer service, arrived early for set up however cake colors were off from the picture I sent. I wanted turquoise and lavender and got purple and sage green. Had to cut cake earlier in the venue than planned as the 2nd layer was leaning forward. Accepted my feedback on a positive note as constructive criticism and discounted the original deposit from the total price.
Cake Making Services
pro avatar
Maggie O.

Jun 28, 2017

Hired on Thumbtack

Natalie baked and designed our cake for our June 2017 wedding. The cake turned out beautifully, and was delicious!! I've been to many weddings where the cake just tastes "meh" or even awful, but our cake tasted amazing and we kept getting compliments from our guests all night. We chose a brown butter cake with layers of raspberry cream and a vanilla buttercream frosting. The cake and frosting was the perfect consistency. We liked that Natalie uses high quality and all-natural ingredients, and you can really taste the difference. We would highly recommend Natalie and Pastry by Day for wedding cakes.
Wedding Cakes
pro avatar
Steven P.

May 9, 2016

Hired on Thumbtack

Pastry By Day was amazing!! Natalie came to our apartment for a private tasting. She came back to pick up the cake topper that we had purchased, both efforts on her part simplified our life at a very busy and stressful time. She coordinated with our venue and showed up on time. The cake was beautiful and delicious! We had several guests comment on how delicious the cake was and I'm not sure how often that happens. Highly recommended!
Wedding Cakes
pro avatar
Lindsay O.

Feb 20, 2017

Hired on Thumbtack

Natalie made my wedding cake and she did a beautiful job! I didn't really have a strong idea of what I wanted, but she brought together some of my ideas in a really cohesive way and I was so pleased. She was a very cool person and gave me an unbeatable price. Everybody thought the cake was delicious. So glad to have found her!
Wedding Cakes
  • Loading