Savour First Choice Catering
Savour First Choice Catering

Savour First Choice Catering

starting price

Budget per person

Responds within a day

At SAVOUR we want you to think of us FIRST when you are having a gathering of any size or caliber in southwest Florida! we offer an abundant menu to choose from as well as customized menus of any type. we pride ourselves on our experience across all fields and will be able to meet your needs, no matter the cuisine, with the highest expectations. After working for the areas premier caterers, Chef Matt Geiger has decided to take on the market providing first class food paired with outstanding service standards to the public in southwest Florida. With his expertise, and team of professionals, he can make something beautiful evolve from your simple idea. He prides himself on customer service and honest feedback.

Hired 15 times

Serves Fort Myers, FL

Background checked

5 employees

5 years in business

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Apple Pay, Cash, Check, Credit card, Square cash app, Venmo, and Zelle.

Social media

Facebook, Instagram

Featured Projects

84 photos

  • Marco art center donation

    Wedding and Event Catering

Event type

, , , , , , , , , ,


, , , , , , , , , ,


Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness.

Excellent 4.9

17 reviews


Read reviews that mention:

pro avatar
Sharon C.
Oct 6, 2020

Hired on Thumbtack

Hired on Thumbtack

Chef Matt was accommodating and personable. He worked with us to make our private event a wonderful memory! I would absolutely hire Savour First Choice Catering again!

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 6 - 10 guests • Cocktail hour / hors d'oeuvres • Dinner • Standard (basic ingredients) • Dessert • American - casual • American - formal • Italian • Vegetarian or vegan • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • My home, venue, etc.

Savour First Choice Catering's reply
Thank you so much Sharon! Your family was great and such a fun group!
Personal Chef
pro avatar
Barbara C.
Dec 2, 2019

Hired on Thumbtack

Hired on Thumbtack

I had to hire a caterer in a short amt of time and was not familiar with any. I read the review for Savour and booked them. After having many parties in NYC I was hoping my Naples caterer would measure up- I was not disappointed at all!!!! They arrived early, very pleasant staff and met everyone’s needs. Matt’s food was delicious and his presentation was beautiful. Everyone loved the food and I would use Savour again without question.

Details: Holiday party • Cocktail hour or hors d'oeuvres • Dessert • Alcoholic drinks • Mediterranean or Middle Eastern • Small bites • Yes, full service • Home • Yes, full kitchen • 20 - 29 guests • Premium (high end ingredients)

Wedding and Event Catering
pro avatar
Elpida O.
Feb 22, 2020
I had to book a last minute wedding reception for 40-60 people. With 3 days notice and last minute changes, the food was amazing, the staff never stopped smiling, the guests are still talking about it. Bonus, they left the place cleaner than they found it! I will hire them again every time because oh their customer service and amazing food at a great price!
pro avatar
Leni S.
Dec 26, 2019
Chef Matt is amazing and made our wedding an day to remember! Every step of the way even before the wedding he made sure that not only all our culinary questions were answered, but that any questions and fears we had about the wedding were eased! He even reached out to another vendor we were working with to help us with coordinating! I so appreciated his calm positive demeanor! He made this bride and groom feel so taken care of! The food was excellent and it was honestly hard to break away from our delicious meal! Guests raved about everything and everyone kept asking about the delicious food! I can’t say enough, thank you Matt and Savour First Choice Catering!!
pro avatar
Kathleen F.
Nov 14, 2019

Hired on Thumbtack

Hired on Thumbtack

Chef Matt was excellent! His staff was friendly and their food delicious. Everyone enjoyed their service, food and professionalism. I highly recommend them!

Details: Corporate event • Cocktail hour or hors d'oeuvres • Mediterranean or Middle Eastern • French • American - formal • Small bites • Yes, full service • Home • Yes, full kitchen • 100 - 124 guests • Premium (high end ingredients)

Wedding and Event Catering
Background Check

Matthew Geiger

  • Loading