Find a property manager near Cumberland, IN

Find a property manager near Cumberland, IN

8 near you

Find a property manager near Cumberland, IN

8 near you

Give us a few details and we’ll match you with the right pro.

Zip code

Top 8 Property Managers near Cumberland, IN

Property Management Companies Cost Guide

  • $
  • $$
  • $$$
  • $$$$

Q & A

Answers to commonly asked questions from the experts on Thumbtack.

Is it worth having a property manager?

While property managers do cost money, they can provide a lot of value to the client. They have marketing know-how and can advertise and perform showings of your property to the rental market. They can collect rent for you and screen potential tenants. They’ll also deal with tenant complaints and repairs, evictions and late rent. Finally, they can manage bill payments to simplify your paperwork and maximize your mental bandwidth.

Chat with top-rated property managers near you to find out if hiring one is worth the cost.

How do I find a good property manager?

You can find the best property manager in your area by starting with an online search. Compare profiles and ratings, and read customer reviews — these tend to give a snapshot of the manager’s quality of work and customer service. Additionally, customers may post photos of their properties that give an idea of the pro’s attention to detail.

Licensing is required in some states, so check to see your state’s policies on licenses and certification.

Finally, compare quotes and prices from at least three property managers.

Are there ways to be safe if I hire a property manager when social distancing?

If you're hiring a property manager to look after a property that you own, consider the safety implications of in-person visits. Due to the CDC’s social distancing guidelines, it may be difficult for the property manager to collect rent in person or complete certain maintenance tasks. Check with your local government guidelines and consider implementing extra safety measures -- such as wearing a mask and gloves -- if you have to meet with them in person.

What’s the best way to set up a consultation or an appointment with a property manager during the COVID-19 pandemic?

Ask the property manager if they can set up a virtual consultation or remote appointment using a phone or video chat. It’s best to avoid as much in-person contact as possible during the COVID-19 pandemic. If they can talk virtually, ask any questions you have about the work that needs to be done. Ask about their system for handling payments, and see what kinds of precautions they have in place to ensure safety and social distancing. 

Does a property manager need to enter my home?

In most cases, a property manager should not have to enter your home or apartment unless there is a maintenance issue that needs attention. If you are hiring a property manager to look after your property, refer to the CDC’s social distancing guidelines and check on your state or local community rules. Ask the property manager whether they can collect rent through digital methods such as PayPal, Zelle or Venmo, and see if they can communicate with residents through video chat or phone call for maintenance issues. 

Why is property management important?

A property management company can be a landlord’s greatest asset. As a neutral third party, the property manager handles the day-to-day operations of a real estate investment, from a single vacation home to a large apartment building or several rental properties. A property management company can be especially helpful to landlords who own several units and can’t manage each of them individually, or those who live too far from their investment properties to meet with renters and oversee maintenance. Property management is particularly important if your rentals are part of an affordable housing program. To receive financial assistance from the government, the landlord must comply with a complicated set of rules; property management companies should have both experience and expertise in complying with the rules specific to each housing program.

Reviews for Cumberland property managers
Jean R.
We are long distance property owners and needed to have someone who would respond to us and our property needs. Cindy explained her business management and we felt comfortable she would be great property manager.
C & C Associates, LLCC & C Associates, LLC
Muri A.
We enjoy working with Beyond Property Management. We have been very dependent on them, getting a number of projects completed pre/post tenant occupancy. Thank you, team!
Beyond Property ManagementBeyond Property Management
Sarah L.
I just hired Joe to manage a house in Indy. Will report back after tenant is placed. I love the national chain behind a process to the entire thing. He's not just "winging it" The client portal is excellent. Just for context- I'm an experience RE investor with other property managers in other locations.
PMI IndianapolisPMI Indianapolis
Chris R.
I manage rental properties from a distance, so building relationships with reliable professional people are the key to my business. Mickey is someone that I will continue to do business with as he understands the rental market, works efficiently and is exceptionally responsive. He made some unbiased recommendations for repairs and we were able to place a new quality tenant. I would recommend doing business with Mickey Russo.
Russo Realty Group LLCRusso Realty Group LLC
Thumbtack Customer
After researching about 10 property management companies, I chose C and C Associates. Most companies, including C and C, were willing to send me a copy of their contract and lease agreements up from, but C and C stood out because: 1. They don't charge for semi-annual inspections and monthly 'drive-by's. 2. Their prices are considerably more reasonable. 3. Tenants are responsible for repairs due to damages that aren't normal wear and tear. 4. They don't require me to take out workers compensation and liability insurance for the work done by their employees and contractors as so many do. I hope this is helpful to you in your research. I also checked the BBB, Yellow Pages, and Yelp and found no complaints against them. We've just started, but I'm pleased so far.
C & C Associates, LLCC & C Associates, LLC
Ready to find a pro?

See more reviews, compare prices, and hire your favorite pros all with Thumbtack.

Why hire professionals on Thumbtack?
Free to use

You never pay to use Thumbtack: Get cost estimates, contact pros, and even book the job—all for no cost.

Compare prices side-by-side

You’ll know how much your project costs even before booking a pro.

Hire with confidence

With access to 1M+ customer reviews and the pros’ work history, you’ll have all the info you need to make a hire.