1. No results to show.
Explore Services
Join as a pro
Log in
  1. No results to show.
  1. No results to show.
Home
Explore Services
Sign up
Log in

Supreme Eatery

Top Pro

Scheduling
Budget per person

Responds in about 25 min

Thumbtack Guarantee

If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more

If you hire this pro, you’re covered by a money-back guarantee. Learn more

About
From meal preparation, family meals, to special occasions Supreme Eatery provides a stress free experience. Grocery shopping, food preparations, and cleaning the kitchen we do it all. Contact us today to talk about your event and figure out where we fit in to make your day easier.
Overview

Current Top Pro

Hired 249 times

2 similar jobs done near you

Background checked

1 employee

10 years in business

Business hours

Sun12:00 am - 11:59 pmMon12:00 am - 11:59 pm

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Apple Pay, Cash, Credit card, Venmo, and Zelle.

Social media

Instagram

Top Pro status

Top Pros are among the highest-rated, most popular professionals on Thumbtack.

Top Pro Icon

2025

Top Pro Icon

2024

Top Pro Icon

2023

Top Pro Icon

2022

Services offered
Event type
Additional food/drink

Dessert

Cold beverages (non-alcoholic)

Cold beverages (alcoholic)

Hot beverages (coffee, tea, etc.)

Cuisine types

American - casual

American - formal

Italian

Southern

Projects and media
Projects and media
Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness.

Exceptional 5.0

160 reviews

5

99%

4

1%

3

0%

2

0%

1

0%

Read reviews that mention:

pro avatar
Jeremy P.

5 days ago

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Chef Janay was absolutely fantastic in all regards. I wanted to surprise my now fiancé with a private chef experience after I proposed, and Janay really delivered. She crafted a vegetarian tasting menu that was truly exciting even for a big meat/fish eater like me. Every single course was wonderful. She delivered big flavor from the pear/brie crostini, goat cheese bites, garlic parm tofu wings (literally fantastic. She’s a genius), to the stunning marry-me butter beans entree and a seasonal peach dessert. Beyond the food and drink (she made great palomas for us), she was incredibly friendly and professional. We enjoyed chatting with her throughout the night. She cleaned up well after dinner, went over the leftovers with us, and left us extremely satisfied. I would recommend her without hesitation for any event.

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 2 guests • Dinner • Premium (high end ingredients) • Dessert • Cold beverages (alcoholic) • American - casual • American - formal • Italian • Mexican / Latin American • Mediterranean / Middle Eastern • Asian • Vegetarian or vegan • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • At the pro’s location • My home, venue, etc.

Personal Chef
pro avatar
Laurie B.

4 weeks ago

•

Hired on Thumbtack

We had the best experience with Janay! It was my husband’s 50th birthday and it was such a treat to be cooked for. The food was absolutely amazing. Everyone loved it. Janay was wonderful as well. She was super organized, neat and left our kitchen as clean as it was before she came. I would highly recommend her service.

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 3 - 5 guests • Dinner • Premium (high end ingredients) • American - formal • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • My home, venue, etc.

Personal Chef
pro avatar
Calluna S.

Feb 15, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Billy was our chef for my husband's surprise birthday. We are vegan, and he was absolutely incredible! I asked for some difficult dishes like vegan creme brulee, and every single course was delicious! I'm relatively picky, and Billy was happy to create a menu I was excited for. He uses in-season ingredients that are fresh and flavorful. He's super responsive to messaging and worked with me so much to perfect the menu. He arrived on time, as scheduled. Scheduling was easy, payment was easy, and I'm overall so pleased. One of the best meals we've had! I highly recommend this private chef service! Thank you!

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 2 guests • Dinner • Dessert • Premium (high end ingredients) • Dessert • Italian • American - formal • Southern • Asian • French • Barbecue • Indian • Mediterranean / Middle Eastern • Mexican / Latin American • Vegetarian or vegan • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • My home, venue, etc.

Personal Chef
pro avatar
Alexandra E.

Jan 29, 2026

•

Hired on Thumbtack

Don’t let Janay’s humble modesty fool you—this girl slays. I have no idea how she manages the chaos of cooking in unfamiliar kitchens on a day as high-stakes as a wedding, but she did it with total ease, consistent smile, and a calm, confident, friendly presence. I can’t recommend her and her team of trusty helpers enough. Oh—and the food was outstanding. One of our guests said Janay’s scallops were the best she’s ever had.

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 21 - 35 guests • Dinner • Cocktail hour / hors d'oeuvres • Dessert • Premium (high end ingredients) • Dessert • Cold beverages (alcoholic) • Cold beverages (non-alcoholic) • Hot beverages (coffee, tea, etc.) • Southern • French • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • My home, venue, etc. • At the pro’s location

Personal Chef
pro avatar
Alex M.

Sep 28, 2025

•

Hired on Thumbtack

We had an incredible meal for my wife’s birthday with Chef Janay ! The food was incredible and the kitchen was cleaner after she finished than before she started cooking. We 100% will be using her service again !

Details: Special occasion (birthday, anniversary, etc.) • 3 - 5 guests • Dinner • I'm flexible • Dessert • American - formal • Italian • Southern • Mexican / Latin American • Asian • Meal prepared onsite • Only once • My home, venue, etc.

Personal Chef
Credentials
Background Check

Janay Newton

  • Loading

Related cost information

Popular in Lakewood

You might also like

In other nearby areas

Thumbtack
Consider it done.
Customers
Pros
Support
© 2026 Thumbtack, Inc.
Thumbtack Guarantee