A note to our community regarding COVID-19. Learn more
Keily Cakes, LLC
Keily Cakes, LLC

Keily Cakes, LLC

Offers remote services
Discounts available
Offers remote services
Discounts available
contact for price

Select a service
Zip code
Cake type
Cake flavor(s)

It’s free, with no obligation to book

Introduction: Keily Cakes is currently offering a 15% discount for clients that order for the months of May, June, and July. (does not include taxes and delivery. May not be combined with other deals or discounts) Mention THUMBTACK15 to receive your discount. ________________________ Who We Are: We are a luxury artisan cake company focusing on rich and bold flavors and specialize in modern, unique and novelty cakes for all special events. We focus on using the highest quality ingredients like European style butter, Belgian chocolate, local flour, real cream, our own gluten-free blend, handmade extracts, and many more. We also offer gluten-free and vegan options because no one should miss out on cake! Currently, our team operates out of a shared commercial kitchen, but offer delivery services to parts of Brooklyn, parts of Queens, and Manhattan. Please inquire for a delivery quote. Pick-up is also available. Let us create memories with you and for you through our delicious confections - you'll surely be the talk of your next celebration.

Serves Brooklyn, NY

Background checked

2 employees

7 years in business

Payment methods

Apple Pay, Credit card, Google Pay, Zelle

Social media

Facebook, Instagram

This pro indicated that they reviewed CDC safety guidelines for COVID-19 and pledged to do the following:

Maintain 6 feet of distance from customers

Wear masks during the job

Wear gloves during the job

Disinfect surfaces touched during the job

Featured Projects

28 photos

  • Abstract Fairy Birthday

    Wedding Cakes

  • Royalty Unicorn Birthday Cake

    Wedding Cakes

  • Black and Gold Modern Rosette Cake

    Wedding Cakes


Customers rated this pro highly for professionalism, work quality, and value.


2 reviews


Gladis R.

I ordered a chocolate cake from here and I was very surprised with the flavor because it was very different from what Im used to have. The cake was very moist, super flavorful, indeed delicious. The baker Keily is also very responsible, professional and works with you to the best of her abilities to exceed your expectations.
Keily Cakes, LLC's reply
Oh wow, thank you so much Gladis. I am so glad you loved the chocolate cake!
Apr 20, 2021
Erica K.

Keily is amazing. She is my go to dessert person. I love everything Keily Cakes. The cookies, cakes, decorations, different tastes... She does not sacrifice looks for taste. Everything tastes as good as it looks or better. Most recently I had the chocolate cake-decadent and rich! I essentially just told her my favorite colors and 'things' I liked and the cake she created for my birthday was phenomenal. She is extremely talented and pays close attention to finer details. She is great at making your ideas come to life. I think the chocolate cakes have been my favorite. But it is all delicious. The vanilla cookies are also a favorite. Soooooooooo tasty. I was very upset when my husband discovered how good the cookies were and I had to share. Everything I have tried from Keily Cakes is stellar. Sometimes I don't even want to eat the dessert because it looks so beautiful. Her artistry is amazing. I am sad I'm not in NY anymore or I'd make up occasions to buy big cakes. It's worth every penny. I cannot sing enough high praises for this business.
Keily Cakes, LLC's reply
Thank you so much for the great review, Erica! I had so much fun making it!
Apr 20, 2021
Background Check

Keily Martinez


  • What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?

    Due to the nature of this business my prices are not set. Each cake client is different, therefore, each cake design is different, which then affects the pricing. Have your budget in mind and we could give you different options within that budget.

  • What is your typical process for working with a new customer?

    In general, clients reach out to me with a pinterest image they have in mind. However, I truly encourage all my clients to choose their favorite elements from the design and allow us to create something original and to their taste. The reason we do this is 1) we want your cake to be as special as you are 2) that is another cake artist's design and 3) we don't copy other cake designs. I will listen to your story, details about your event, and come up with three options for you to choose from that best meets your style and budget. Once you have chosen your option, flavors, colors, etc. You will receive an invoice. Once you pay, you will then receive three (3) sketches to choose from. We'll set your pick-up or delivery, and then you leave the rest in our hands! The evening of the delivery/pick-up you will receive a professional photo of your cake so that you have as a keepsake and will be tagged on our social media platforms if you have provided us with your handle(s)

  • What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?

    I am self taught through the University of YouTube, along with other courses I have taken along the way to perfect my craft. Prior to this I had experience in art, photography, and business.

Not what you’re looking for?

No problem: we have pros for every job.