Join as a pro
Explore
Log in
Home
Sign up
Log in
Find a cake maker near New York, NY

Top 9 cake makers near New York, NY

Pros with the highest ratings.Pros who have been hired most often.Pros who respond to customers the fastest.Pros who have the most reviews.These are the top 10 pros for your job.

Pros with the highest ratings.Pros who have been hired most often.Pros who respond to customers the fastest.Pros who have the most reviews.These are the top 10 pros for your job.

Avatar for Rosy’s Cups and Cakes
Avatar for Rosy’s Cups and Cakes
1.
Rosy’s Cups and Cakes
1.
Rosy’s Cups and Cakes

Great 4.7

(25)

Great 4.7

(25)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services, Wedding Cakes

In high demand
  • 25 hires on Thumbtack
  • 2 similar jobs done near you
Shreya N. says, "Both cakes were absolute as asked to be made. The chocolate cake was pure indulgence! The rich, moist layers melted in my mouth with every bite. The chocolate frosting was velvety smooth, striking the perfect balance between sweet and bitter. I would absolutely recommend for special occasions or simply to satisfy a chocolate craving!"See more
Shreya N. says, "Both cakes were absolute as asked to be made. The chocolate cake was pure indulgence! The rich, moist layers melted in my mouth with every bite. The chocolate frosting was velvety smooth, striking the perfect balance between sweet and bitter. I would absolutely recommend for special occasions or simply to satisfy a chocolate craving!"
Avatar for Brooklyn Custom Cakes & Desserts
Avatar for Brooklyn Custom Cakes & Desserts
2.
Brooklyn Custom Cakes & Desserts
2.
Brooklyn Custom Cakes & Desserts

5.0

(2)

5.0

(2)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services, Wedding Cakes

  • Serves New York, NY
Ariel A. says, "I wanted a cat-themed cake for my birthday, and Brooklyn Custom Cakes and Desserts made my dream come true. Tanisha is very thoughtful, creative and collaborative when it comes to crafting a custom cake to your visual and taste preferences. She is a delight to work with and very professional and punctual. The cake had my friends taking pictures of it and asking for seconds. I highly recommend Brooklyn Custom Cakes and will be using them for all my cake needs in the future."See more
Ariel A. says, "I wanted a cat-themed cake for my birthday, and Brooklyn Custom Cakes and Desserts made my dream come true. Tanisha is very thoughtful, creative and collaborative when it comes to crafting a custom cake to your visual and taste preferences. She is a delight to work with and very professional and punctual. The cake had my friends taking pictures of it and asking for seconds. I highly recommend Brooklyn Custom Cakes and will be using them for all my cake needs in the future."
Avatar for Guicy Gems
Avatar for Guicy Gems
3.
Guicy Gems
3.
Guicy Gems

Exceptional 5.0

(12)

Exceptional 5.0

(12)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services, Wedding Cakes

  • 5 hires on Thumbtack
  • Serves New York, NY
Michelle W. says, "My experience with this vendor was spectacular. She is very responsive, friendly and all around amazing from start to finish. She went above and beyond to make sure my daughter’s day was a special one. Our cake and dessert table looked and tasted like heaven. I would definitely be using her for all my cake needs in the future. I highly recommend doing a tasting with her. She’s very professional and accommodating. I bet you’ll hire her after you taste her samples!"See more
Michelle W. says, "My experience with this vendor was spectacular. She is very responsive, friendly and all around amazing from start to finish. She went above and beyond to make sure my daughter’s day was a special one. Our cake and dessert table looked and tasted like heaven. I would definitely be using her for all my cake needs in the future. I highly recommend doing a tasting with her. She’s very professional and accommodating. I bet you’ll hire her after you taste her samples!"
Avatar for The Queens Cookie
Avatar for The Queens Cookie
4.
The Queens Cookie
4.
The Queens Cookie

Exceptional 5.0

(6)

Exceptional 5.0

(6)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services

  • 1 hire on Thumbtack
  • Serves New York, NY
Liana T. says, "Christina made an incredible cake for my baby shower. To this day, all my guests rave about the beautiful design. It was a truly one a kind cake with a clear attention to detail. The cake wasn’t just all show but delicious too! I highly, highly recommend The Queens Cookie for anyone who is looking for high quality, well designed, and tasty baked goods."See more
Liana T. says, "Christina made an incredible cake for my baby shower. To this day, all my guests rave about the beautiful design. It was a truly one a kind cake with a clear attention to detail. The cake wasn’t just all show but delicious too! I highly, highly recommend The Queens Cookie for anyone who is looking for high quality, well designed, and tasty baked goods."
Avatar for Aromas Boutique Bakery
Avatar for Aromas Boutique Bakery
8.
Aromas Boutique Bakery
8.
Aromas Boutique Bakery

5.0

(2)

5.0

(2)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services

  • Serves New York, NY
Alyssa Bernstein says, "I cannot recommend the wonderful women at Aromas enough! When you google "custom vegan gender reveal/birthday cake" not much comes up...however, I somehow found Aromas where they truly make magic. A fully vegan cake that is rich, delicious, and so beautifully made. On top of that, she helped my vision of a 40th birthday/gender reveal cake come TRUE. Jo-Ann is wonderful to work with, communicative, patient and professional. I hope to have many more happy occasions for their delicious cakes!"See more
Alyssa Bernstein says, "I cannot recommend the wonderful women at Aromas enough! When you google "custom vegan gender reveal/birthday cake" not much comes up...however, I somehow found Aromas where they truly make magic. A fully vegan cake that is rich, delicious, and so beautifully made. On top of that, she helped my vision of a 40th birthday/gender reveal cake come TRUE. Jo-Ann is wonderful to work with, communicative, patient and professional. I hope to have many more happy occasions for their delicious cakes!"
Avatar for The Velvetine Supper Club & Events
Avatar for The Velvetine Supper Club & Events
9.
The Velvetine Supper Club & Events
9.
The Velvetine Supper Club & Events

Good 4.3

(16)

Good 4.3

(16)

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services

In high demand
  • 27 hires on Thumbtack
  • Serves New York, NY

Online now

Eric W. says, "Valentine’s Day Perfection – 5 Stars! I had the pleasure of booking The Velvetine Supper Club for a private Valentine’s Day dinner, and the experience was nothing short of amazing! Our chef was not only incredibly talented but also so kind and professional, making the evening feel effortless and special. The meal was beautifully curated, starting with an innovative first course of fresh fruit with rich chocolate dipping sauce—a fun and unexpected way to begin the night. Next came a luxurious lobster risotto, perfectly creamy and packed with flavor. The star of the show was the steak with truffle butter, cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. From the seamless service to the exquisite flavors, everything was top-notch. I would definitely book again and highly recommend The Velvetine Supper Club for anyone looking to elevate their at-home dining experience. Thank you for an unforgettable evening! 💕✨"See more
Eric W. says, "Valentine’s Day Perfection – 5 Stars! I had the pleasure of booking The Velvetine Supper Club for a private Valentine’s Day dinner, and the experience was nothing short of amazing! Our chef was not only incredibly talented but also so kind and professional, making the evening feel effortless and special. The meal was beautifully curated, starting with an innovative first course of fresh fruit with rich chocolate dipping sauce—a fun and unexpected way to begin the night. Next came a luxurious lobster risotto, perfectly creamy and packed with flavor. The star of the show was the steak with truffle butter, cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. From the seamless service to the exquisite flavors, everything was top-notch. I would definitely book again and highly recommend The Velvetine Supper Club for anyone looking to elevate their at-home dining experience. Thank you for an unforgettable evening! 💕✨"

There are 144 five star cake makers in New York, NY on Thumbtack.

Why hire professionals on Thumbtack?
Free to use

You never pay to use Thumbtack: Get cost estimates, contact pros, and even book the job—all for no cost.

Compare prices side-by-side

You’ll know how much your project costs even before booking a pro.

Hire with confidence

With access to 1M+ customer reviews and the pros’ work history, you’ll have all the info you need to make a hire.

Related cost information

Popular in New York

You might also like

In other nearby areas

Thumbtack
Consider it done.
Customers
Pros
Support
© 2025 Thumbtack, Inc.
Thumbtack Guarantee