Cleveland, OH5 Ice Cream Caterers near you

Where do you need the ice cream caterer?

Answer a few questions

Tell us what you need so we can bring you the right pros.

Get quotes

Receive quotes from pros who meet your needs.

Hire the right pro

Compare quotes, message pros, and hire when ready.

Cleveland Ice Cream Caterers

Browse these ice cream caterers with great ratings from Thumbtack customers in Cleveland.

  • 23 years in business
  • 24 hires on Thumbtack
Sherica H.
Verified review

Damon and his team made my daughter's birthday party go over the top. His attention to detail is beyond amazing. I explained to him that my family and I had bad experiences with mandatory caterers from venues in the past and I really wanted the food to be the correct temperature. He exceeded my expectations. The menu was amazing but the brisket stole the show. The brisket was so tender and delicious. This team is so down to earth, friendly and talkative my guests and I were very comfortable. My family was excited to find out that a team member is vegan and that catering for my vegan guests in the future would be no problem. So many people requested his information because of their personalities as well. But the ultimate seal of approval that this food was delicious was from my 80 year old Grandparents that asked me to hire him for their 64th wedding anniversary. They are from Louisiana and have been cooking since they were kids and my grandfather smokes his meat for all our family events. They both said, "his food is so delicious, we can rest this year". Damon made my event wonderful for everyone. He made my daughter a ice cream buffet with all the fixings. She said, "This is the best birthday ever" His professionalism blew me away, the presentation was amazing. I am still over the moon with how the event went last night.

  • 4 years in business
  • 36 hires on Thumbtack
Laura S.
Verified review

Marnie was excellent! She knew how to get pictures of everybody, had plenty of props and was so easy to work with.Everyone loved the photo booth and had great pictures to take home. The album she made to take home was icing on the cake! Thanks Marnie!

Piccadilly Artisan Creamery
from 3 reviews
  • 4 years in business
Lori S.
Verified review

Loved working with Piccadilly! Their ice cream is amazing. I highly recommend the crème fraiche with the balsamic roasted strawberries, my personal favorite. However, all their flavors are incredible. All the guests at my corporate event thought the ice cream and how they make it with liquid nitrogen was fascinating. I hope that I get the opportunity to work with them again in the future.

Scott's Fire & Ice
from 2 reviews
  • 7 years in business
  • 6 hires on Thumbtack
Mallory P.
Verified review

Appetizers, salad and pizza! Everything was so yummy and fresh! Even after Scott made extra pizzas, there were no leftovers!!! The gelato and sorbet was also amazing! Scott and his pizza crew are wonderful to work with!

Comfort Catering
from 1 review
    Joyce W.
    Verified review

    I love having friends over but do not have the time for all of the work and preparation that goes along with entertaining them. There is something so intimate about having people in your home that is difficult to recreate in a restaurant. I was able to host a party in my home, and was able to use my favorite linens, serving dishes and decorate with extra special touches. But of course shopping and cooking all of the appetizers and food I wanted to serve was time-consuming. A big caterer was not cost effective for my gathering. I found COMFORT CATERING, the owner prepares home cooked meals ready to serve. The presentation was lovely. There was an option for help with set up or serving, ready to serve or prepared in house as well as clean-up. The catering experience was comfortable and affordable. My guests enjoyed the appetizers and the entrees and finding a great caterer afforded me the time to visit with my friends, soon the caterer became the topic of conversation. When it comes to COMFORT CATERING, comfort is the key word, you feel comfortable and relaxed, the fresh food and personal touches are reminiscent of comfort food and knowing you will use them again eases your mind when you know you have a go-to-caterer. Delish! I also used COMFORT CATERING for a small corporate Halloween event. The personal touches were spooktacular, from the ice hand, the appetizer eyeballs, fingers, bats, dry ice around the pot of brew punch. So much detail, the presentation was fantastic and was the centerpiece of the party. I recommend COMFORT CATERING and my friends have used comfort catering for pool parties, barbecues, graduation parties and more. Well done! ~JW~

    Hire skilled professionals for absolutely everything.